Psaltis is of French, Greek and Italian descent.
Dawn married the father of her son, Matthew in June 2005.
On December 20, 2005, Psaltis gave birth to her first child, a boy named Matthew. He was born seven days prematurely. In January 2006, she filed a complaint against WWE with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, claiming that her contract had been wrongfully terminated as a result of her pregnancy, and that she had suffered mental duress as a result of the release. She maintains that Kenney is not the father.
Psaltis is good friends with several other female wrestlers, including Torrie Wilson, Stacey Keibler, Jackie Gayda, Lita aned Victoria. She attended the wedding of Wilson and Billy Kidman and was a bidesmaid at Jackie Gayda's marriage to Charlie Haas. She and fellow ECW alumna Francine share a mutual dislike for unknown reasons.